Only rare if it is never discontinued. Make it the next rainbow cape if it must be rare. Otherwise any new tradable rares are just a desperate mans excuse to cheat a quick profit by hoarding as many as they can on release and sitting on unfairly raising inflating wealth.
Everybody here in support of a new tradable rare is desperately trying to make an easy profit. Quit selfishly making this game easyscape for the rich alone. Existing discontinued items are already overpowered. Use those while you still can.
Your opinions here can affect us all. Please post for the better