Forums

BD# / Siggy Guide - Revamp?Thread is locked

Quick find code: 55-56-725-65725712

Samsaurus99

Samsaurus99

Posts: 15,714Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
H
m
m
m
m
.
.

I don't personally see much benefit to a merge as both threads have a completely different tone to them as others have pointed out earlier in the argument. I'd say the signatures one is a lot more informative as customised signatures would now be a bigger deal for the common poster with the added signature tool whereas I've always thought of the BD# thread as a big community sketchbook where you are free to create whatever, without the fear of drowning out text or the smaller stuff - which is a lot more customary in the signatures sticky, with people asking formatting questions or making short >200 character tags for their posts. I think if anything it'd create a big jumble of mis-matching art that would throw people off as signatures and logos vary quite a lot in style and usage. It could be intimidating to see huge multiple-post-spanning logos and maybe puts people off making smaller more personal designs.


Also like this point:

NopRs said:
I think the threads in their current format (two separate sig/logo threads) are the most inviting to people completely new to forum art. I just don't think as many people will want to go to page 2 of a thread that they don't know much about. In terms of exposure, I think two individual threads with the most important info on the first page with the current titles is best.



I would honestly say thread owner activity is not an issue for BD# as it is not a thread needed to be 'regulated' or updated (although some sort of bulletin board and advertisment as others have suggested would be nice) as it's a fairly self-explanatory thread.

I'm sorry but I don't really like the idea and I'm a bit puzzled as to why this is being brought up ...

03-Jan-2016 01:17:19

Samsaurus99

Samsaurus99

Posts: 15,714Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
NopRs said:
Copier List: [lol]
Toast Cy (a.k.a. king soups, amos kane, wi fi, king patar,andrep***you)



huuuuuuuuuhhh


I have this guy on my friends list he used to make signatures too

Also I'm kinda with Cyan on the logo request thing, since there's no other place to request logos and ascii it could be flooded with apps and take away from the actual thread purpose

07-Jan-2016 22:56:03 - Last edited on 07-Jan-2016 22:58:37 by Samsaurus99

Quick find code: 55-56-725-65725712Back to Top