Forums

Who Would Win?

Quick find code: 341-342-304-65794307

of 2
AesirWarrior

AesirWarrior

Posts: 1,054Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
IF YOU DON'T CARE ABOUT THE INTRODUCTION JUST LOOK AT THE NEXT POST

I seem to recall Chaos Lupus made a similar thread ages ago, but sadly it seems like The Page 51 Monster ate it. This probably won't go anywhere, but it's worth a shot. Consider this an experiment.


Pretty simple premise, someone picks a couple of characters and then the rest try to decide who'd win in a fight. You know, the standard thing comicbook nerds do on forums all over the internet.

No special rules really. That being said, the main point of this thread is just to discuss power levels, fighting skill and so on, so try to stay somewhat on topic.

A few things worth mentioning though (guidelines):

- In-Game stats are made with a priority of making the game playable and enjoyable, not keeping a character consistent
- Gameplay often contradicts lore evidence
(shamelessly taken from a thread on reddit).

Just because * is a harder boss than Y doesn't mean that it's necessarily stronger in-universe. Look at what we know these characters can do within the universe of Runescape. Don't look at hit splats, HP and stats. These are made with gameplay rather than story in mind. The line between canon and non-canon mechanics is a bit fussy though, so a lot of this stuff is up for debate.

Anyway the gist of it is that Story > Gameplay when debating this stuff.

Oh and as for sources of Lore I'd say it's something like this:

Feats (what they've been shown to do) > Statements by J-mods (Example: "Zamorak could eat Brassica Prime - Mod FakeZam) > Character statements (Example: "I can bench-press Varrock" - Fake Zemouregal ). Memories are probably accurate enough to go in the first category.

* The letter X is censored for some reason.



PROPOSED MATCHES BELOW
-
I have noticed your kind does tend to blindly stumble forward towards danger simply because it exists. What is your word for that?
- We call it being a hero.

22-May-2016 01:58:31

AesirWarrior

AesirWarrior

Posts: 1,054Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
WHO WOULD WIN?
(No you don't have to answer them all, or any of them)

All four GWD generals (Kree vs K'ril vs Zilyana vs Graardor). No Nex.
Round 1: In one of their chambers. None other than the generals are present.
Round 2: Out in the open. The four generals find themselves teleported to a seemingly endless field.

All four GWD armies. Still No Nex.
Round 1: In the Dungeon. Just imagine what the outcome of the current battle would be.
Round 2: Infinite field again (more space).

K'ril Tsutsaroth vs Nymora and Avaryss
Round 1: In K'rils chamber
Round 2: In The Furies' chamber (does it make a difference?)

ROTM Lucien VS Current Sliske
Round 1: No Minions
Round 2: Minions allowed

The Drakans (Lowerniel, Vanescula, Ranis and Draynor) VS The ROTS Barrows Brothers.
Round 1: Drakans vs ROTS Barrows Brothers (like the title says). Someplace in Morytania.
Round 2: Lowerniel vs The Brothers.
Round 3: Regular Brothers vs Ranis and Draynor.

Baxtorian VS Azzanadra
Round 1: Inside Senntisten's temple.
Round 2: Endless, open field.

Zamorak vs The Desert Pantheon
Round 1: In the desert.
Round 2: Purely physical fight. No magic beyond augmeting their own bodies.
Round 3-4: Same thing (both rounds) except replace Zamorak with Saradomin.

Zamorak vs Saradomin
Round 1: Standard Fight. No allies allowed.
Round 2: Same as above except with equalised tiers.
Round 3: Chess

Icthlarin vs The Mahjarrat
Round 1: Standard fight - In the middle of The Kharidian Desert.
Round 2: Iccy has Amascut
Only the mahjarrat currently alive (and Zamorak doesn't count).

Nomad vs Zemouregal
Round 1: Standard 1v1
Round 2: Arrav vs Nomad.

Nex vs Azzanadra
Round 1: Standard 1v1
Round 2: Nex has has her four mages (whose names I always forget).

These are just a few examples. Add your own if you want. I might add some more if this becomes popular
-
I have noticed your kind does tend to blindly stumble forward towards danger simply because it exists. What is your word for that?
- We call it being a hero.

22-May-2016 02:05:18

Lethalintent
Dec Gold Premier Club Member 2012

Lethalintent

Posts: 7,343Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
AesirWarrior said:


All four GWD generals (Kree vs K'ril vs Zilyana vs Graardor). No Nex.
Round 1: K'ril
Round 2: Hmm, K'ril.

All four GWD armies. Still No Nex.
Round 1: Stalemate
Round 2: As above

K'ril Tsutsaroth vs Nymora and Avaryss
Round 1: Twins
Round 2: Twins

ROTM Lucien VS Current Sliske
Round 1: Sliske
Round 2: Sliske

The Drakans (Lowerniel, Vanescula, Ranis and Draynor) VS The ROTS Barrows Brothers.
Round 1: Drakans
Round 2: Brothers
Round 3: Regular brothers

Baxtorian VS Azzanadra
Round 1: Azzanadra
Round 2: Azzanadra

Zamorak vs The Desert Pantheon
Round 1: Zamorak
Round 2: Zamorak
Round 3-4: Saradomin

Zamorak vs Saradomin
Round 1: Stalemate
Round 2: Stalemate
Round 3: Saradomin

Icthlarin vs The Mahjarrat
Round 1: Mahjarrat
Round 2: Mahjarrat
Only the mahjarrat currently alive (and Zamorak doesn't count).

Nomad vs Zemouregal
Round 1: Nomad
Round 2: Nomad

Nex vs Azzanadra
Round 1: Azzanadra- As confirmed by Jmods
Round 2: See above.
Zarosian Lorehound

Master Questcape Owner

Inconsistent Completionist

22-May-2016 03:32:49

Eridyn
Dec Gold Premier Club Member 2010

Eridyn

Posts: 2,945Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
World Guardian vs Everyone
Round 1. World Guardian.
Round 2. (Non-canon) Everyone, so the World Guardian can see what would happen.
@Eriddyn
|
Lorehound
| [
Role-Player
| "A flame can never be a star, no matter how bright it burns." -
Jas
.

22-May-2016 03:55:54

Hazeel

Hazeel

Posts: 6,720Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
All four GWD generals

Zilyana has beaten Kree, and K'ril has beaten Zilyana. Graardor is an unknown, but K'ril has shown more domiance, so I'll say K'ril for both rounds.

All four GWD armies. Still No Nex.
Round 1: Hard to tell. It feels like Zamorak's is the strongest, but it's also the most targeted.
Round 2: I'd lean more to Zamorak's here.

K'ril Tsutsaroth vs Nymora and Avaryss
Since Zamorak has them fighting a more important battle, I'll say the Furies for both.

ROT* Lucien VS Current Sliske
Round 1: Lucien easily.
Round 2: Harder to call. I'll say Lucien narrowly.

The Drakans (Lowerniel, Vanescula, Ranis and Draynor) VS The ROTS Barrows Brothers.
Round 1: Drakan.
Round 2: Drakan.
Round 3: Brothers.

Baxtorian VS Azzanadra
Round 1: Azzanad*a easily.
Round 2: Azzanad*a easily.

Zamorak vs The Desert Pantheon
Round 1: Zamorak.
Round 2: Zamorak.
Round 3: Saradomin.
Round 4: ...Mmm...do tiers help with physical fights? I'm assuming not, so...Pantheon.

Zamorak vs Saradomin
Round 1: Hard to tell.
Round 2: Zamorak.
Round 3: Undecided. Saradomin keeps upending the board when he's losing.

Icthlarin vs The Mahjarrat
Round 1: Mahjarrat.
Round 2: Mahjarrat.

Nomad vs Zemouregal
Round 1: Zemourgal.
Round 2: Nomad.

Nex vs Azzanadra
Round 1: Nex.
Round 2: Azzanadra.........dropped the soap.
Runescape doesn't need a hero...it needs a villain. An all encompassing force of evil that will remain ever-threatening and use chaos to make the peoples of Gielinor tolerate each other, grow strong together, and fight side by side against this evil. I am that villain.

22-May-2016 04:03:49

Hguoh
Mar Gold Premier Club Member 2014

Hguoh

Posts: 7,442Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
All four GWD generals
Round 1: Almost certainly Kril.
Round 2: Largely a stalemate, but Kril would outlive the others.

All four GWD armies
Round 1: We know how this is: Stalemate.
Round 2: Zamorak's army certainly seems the most powerful, but he'd equally be the most targeted. Bandos's army's continual side flipping would largely prevent them from claiming victory. I'd probably have to go with Saradomin's army due to the mind reading/control necklaces.

Kril vs Furies
Round 1: Furies
Round 2: Furies (Kril is likely the better general, given that he was chosen to lead Zamorak's army in the most significant power struggle at the time while the Furies were acting as his executioners, but the Furies are likely the better combatants)

Lucien vs Sliske
Round 1: Sliske (he's not exactly going to fight fair)
Round 2: Sliske (it would just be a repeat of RotM)

Drakans vs ROTS Barrows Bros
Round 1: Bros (they were able to threaten the Drakans and their armies so much so that it took Sliske's intervention to stop them)
Round 2: Bros
Round 3:Bros

Baxtorian vs Azzanadra
Round 1: Neither (Azzy would have the advantage, but they'd likely be crushed to death when they inevitably bring the cave down around them)
Round 2: Azzy (Baxtorian's magic is impressive, moving mountains, forming rives, etc... but I feel Azzy's direct combat magic gives him the edge in this case)

Zamorak vs Desert Pantheon
Round 1: Zamorak (unless armies and other gods are involved, in which case: stalemate)
Round 2: Zamorak
Round 3-4: replace Zammy with Sara in the previous 2

Zammy vs Saradomin
Round 1: Uncertain (Zammy's got the technique and strats, but Sara's got the power, and Zammy doesn't have the SIphon this time)
Round 2: Probably Zammy
Round 3: Neither (both would rather destroy the board than lose)

Icthlarin vs Mahjarrat
Round 1: Need I point out the Zarosian/Kharidian War? Mahjarrat
Round 2: Mahjarrat (Amascut would help them)

22-May-2016 04:41:30 - Last edited on 22-May-2016 04:42:07 by Hguoh

Hguoh
Mar Gold Premier Club Member 2014

Hguoh

Posts: 7,442Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Nomad vs Zemo
Round 1: Zemo tends to rely on his undead and other minions to supplement his combat skills. So in a 1v1, I have to hand it to Nomad
Round 2: Just Arrav, no Zemo? Nomad

Nex vs Azz*
Round 1: Probably Azzy (much of Nex's threat and presence came from the Legion she has, but she can't use it in this scenario)
Round 2: Again, probably Azzy (I said, Legion, not just the 4 mages)

22-May-2016 04:50:27

AesirWarrior

AesirWarrior

Posts: 1,054Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Round 4: ...Mmm...do tiers help with physical fights? I'm assuming not, so...Pantheon.

@ Hazeel: He can stilll use his powers to augment his own body. So more power probably means he could make his body stronger and more durable.

Icthlarin vs Mahjarrat
Round 1: Need I point out the Zarosian/Kharidian War? Mahjarrat
@HGUOG: To be fair that was hundreds of mahjarrat, while now there are only around 11 (I think), but I get your point. I also have to say I kind of forgot about Kharshai, Sliske and Bilrach so it might be more unbalanced than anticipated.

As for Arrav, yeah it's only him. I was kind of uncertain about who'd be a fair fight against Nomad, so I put Arrav there in case that was a more "balanced" fight.
-
I have noticed your kind does tend to blindly stumble forward towards danger simply because it exists. What is your word for that?
- We call it being a hero.

22-May-2016 05:11:29

Kittyphantom

Kittyphantom

Posts: 12,382Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Zamorak vs The Desert Pantheon
Round 1: In the desert.
Round 2: Purely physical fight. No magic beyond augmeting their own bodies.
Round 3-4: Same thing (both rounds) except replace Zamorak with Saradomin.


The Desert Pantheon; Zamorak and Saradomin would be outnumbered, 8 to 1. Especially with no magic - Saradomin's an old man. You expect him to be able to lay the smackdown on 8 opponents with his bare hands?


Zamorak vs Saradomin
Round 1: I don't know. Saradomin's recent "level up" might give him the advantage...
Round 2: ...But here? Would he have won the BoL without support? I don't know. Zamorak's a warrior, and Saradomin's an old man in robes.
Round 3: Saradomin, obviously. God of wisdom. This reminds me of an amazing piece of artwork in one of the last players' galleries, btw (Zamorak was the one who upended the board in that one, while Saradomin sat looking smug)


Icthlarin vs The Mahjarrat
Round 1: Standard fight - In the middle of The Kharidian Desert.
Round 2: Iccy has Amascut
Only the mahjarrat currently alive (and Zamorak doesn't count).

Pssh, no contest, *ESPECIALLY* in Round 2. Icthlarin is one of the gods themselves. He could beat the Mahjarrat with ease - Then siccing a second god on them? Unfair in the extreme.
"You have heard that it was said, 'You shall love your neighbor and hate your enemy.' But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you[...]For if you love those who love you, what reward do you have?

22-May-2016 09:32:07

Quick find code: 341-342-304-65794307Back to Top