Forums

Comp cape without reaper fix

Quick find code: 16-17-779-65992677

Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Posts: 7,198Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Support the idea 100%. Although I recently got the reaper title, I don't want other people to be forced to get it. Especially with the way new bosses are tailored to a specific part of the player base.

Or just add it to trim. Or separate solo bosses for comp and group bosses for trim. Simple as that.

22-May-2018 12:26:57 - Last edited on 22-May-2018 12:28:09 by Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Posts: 7,198Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Loving the idea. Also wanted to leave mine as a derivative to the OP:

Comp cape is received when all skills are maxed (including 120 slayer, invention + dungeoneering). Other requirements can include completion of all songs, all obtainable emotes. Cape has no stats at this point.

Each completionist requirement adds a new perk onto the cape:
- Completion of animal magnetism adds collection of arrows.
- Completion of all quests adds the quest cape perk automatically.
- Completion of fight cape adds the stats of the fire cape.
- Completion of kiln adds the stats of the kiln capes.
- Completion of ardy diaries adds the ardy cape effect.
- Completion of all diaries allows the cape to obtain their (when held in inventory) effects.
- 1 Kc at the boss adds 1% damage boost against them.
- Reaper title adds 5% boost against all bosses.
- And for the other smaller reqs, this can be a running theme. Add a small boost for completion of such activities.

I think it would make the comp cape more balanced, and remove the need for people to complete content that is dead, just to tick the box on the "completed" scale. Then players can specialise their cape for the activity they enjoy. (e.g. obtain the elven title to increase damage against elves).

Then new requirements can be added to make the cape more lucrative. Some requirements from trim can also be brought down to the comp cape level. Some cosmetic or memory requirements can be put onto trim, as they serve no beneficial purpose.

Just my though, let me know if you agree or disagree with any of the points made. I am not creating my own thread, because I think that the idea supplements OP instead of providing something completely different.

29-May-2018 05:10:46 - Last edited on 29-May-2018 05:17:01 by Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Posts: 7,198Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Well, this is more relevant than ever, considering that the cape is now locked behind the "unlock music during the fight" and "get a kill for reaper". It feels that they are not listening. Well, if they won't listen, I won't support them financially.

29-May-2018 15:46:29

Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Posts: 7,198Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
KitKat3303 said:
No support. If you suck so much that you physically can't get the reaper title then you don't deserve to have a cape that says you completed the entirety of the game. If we keep petitioning to devalue the comp cape even people like me will own one and it'll ruin the idea of the cape.

Every resource in the game should be completely free and generated by console commanding it into my inventory and in return the skills that give the resources should gain exp at 20x the rates because I don't feel like grinding stats I don't like to 120-200m. Not having difficult requirements for comp is nice, not having an endless grind to get my stats up is also nice, but that doesn't make it a good idea.


This is why we have trim comp, so that stupid requirements like reaper can go for people who just want gold particles.

By your logic, we need to put 5.4b xp as a comp req, and completion of all content. But then you are not complete yet. Need to have a 5.4b hardcore ironman, ultimate ironman and normal ironman. Must have obtained all TH promotion items. Must have been at every seasonal event since the inception of the game.

Stop with the stupid line of reasoning that if people can't get reaper, than the cape is devalued. Only thing that the reaper does is say that you managed to last the last 10% of the kill on yaka, defeated telos at 0% enrage, and massed other bosses in RS. It was prestigious enough before the reaper requirement, I don't understand how is it not prestigious and hard to get without it. You still need to complete majority of the game's content. (the one that counts anyway)

29-May-2018 16:24:33

Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Posts: 7,198Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
RunezScape said:
Learning curve. There was a time QBD was so hard that there were so many graves it caused glitches and Jagex tried to refund a few people.

Please don't compare solo bosses to forced group content. Look at AoD. Massable and people have no problem. Look at Raids and Solak, restricted arbitrarily and everyone has a problem.

31-May-2018 00:28:41

Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Posts: 7,198Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Nex is Life said:
Tom Grey said:
Nex is Life said:
Tom Grey said:
Look at Raids and Solak, restricted arbitrarily and everyone has a problem.
No we don't.

Yes we do.
You're not everyone.

And you think you are? Look at recent updates and how many players have issue with the comp cape being a req. There are many more in game that don't come to forums. Its generally not regarded as good to have SOLAK on comp.

31-May-2018 13:27:35

Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Posts: 7,198Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Nex is Life said:
Tom Grey said:
Nex is Life said:
Tom Grey said:
Nex is Life said:
Tom Grey said:
Look at Raids and Solak, restricted arbitrarily and everyone has a problem.
No we don't.

Yes we do.
You're not everyone.

And you think you are? Look at recent updates and how many players have issue with the comp cape being a req. There are many more in game that don't come to forums. Its generally not regarded as good to have SOLAK on comp.
I didn't claim to be everyone.

Comp isn't there it be handed out, you're supposed to have issues getting it.

It's generally not regarded as good to have Livid farm on comp. But I'm not complaining.

1. Livid farm makes sense since it unlocks spells in your spell book.
2. Livid farm was nerfed to accommodate players who hated it on comp.
3. Solak should be removed from comp to accommodate players who hate it on comp. Thank you for getting my point across.

Also look at your reply to my initial post before you say you didn't claim to be everyone. When you say "we" (I guess this is what you were referring to in my post) you claim to be everyone as well.

31-May-2018 19:36:39

The contents of this message have been hidden

31-May-2018 23:37:55

Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Posts: 7,198Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
N8yCakes said:
Menaphos Slayer Master title is a trim requirement and is essentially the same thing as Reaper title (more kills involved but still). Make Slayer Master comp and Reaper trim, Slayer Master is far easier after all.

Agreed. Slayer master makes more sense to be a comp req than reaper.

01-Jun-2018 22:24:58

Tom Grey

Tom Grey

Posts: 7,198Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Lush Snow said:
yggdrsil said:
yeah Truthfully at the rate it is going I feel just splitting reaper requirement into to two one for solo-able bosses(which would be comp requirement) and then team bossing which would be trim. Also 9 more posts left before thread is full so make them count


Which all of this does nothing for those of us that use legacy. Cheers for nowt as usual.

Did you try revo ++, its better damage and as chill as legacy.

03-Jun-2018 16:46:48

Quick find code: 16-17-779-65992677Back to Top