Forums

Forum Moderation ReviewThread is locked

Quick find code: 254-255-527-65726664

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Moderation Review Thread


This topic cannot be used for account support, technical help or discussion of game content.

If you require account help, please click here


If you post on this thread asking for account help it will be considered misuse of Community Management and may result in account penalties





This thread is to only be used to flag the actions of a Forum Moderator to us should you feel they have acted inappropriately. You should not post here about receiving a forum mute as they are reviewed by Jagex regardless of whether you ask us to or not.

This thread is NOT to be used for any of the following:

XDispute a Forum Mute - Forum mutes are reviewed automatically by Jagex staff
XReport rule breaking - Use 'Forum Help'
XAccount support - Contact Customer Support

This thread can only be used for the following:

Forum Moderator complaints – if you feel an FMod has acted inappropriately or misused their power

Quick Find Code:
Forum Moderator involved:
Page:
Post:
Summary of issue:

All posts made on this topic are automatically hidden and are viewable to Jagex Moderators only. If appropriate you may receive a follow up inbox message when you submit a report, so check your game message centre regularly.

Posting on this thread does not guarantee a response, but all reports will be reviewed and any necessary action will be taken. Posts which don't use the above form risk having their review delayed or not done at all.

Please note all decisions are final - subsequent replies to a JMod review may be ignored.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

04-Jan-2016 09:23:39

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
S z - On post 7 of the thread, it states that KOS bans should be discussed in-game, and this is the better way to do it. Discussions on the thread will only bring flaming and arguments to the forum which isn't good for your community. The rule you're in danger of breaching is Be respectful of your fellow forumers at all times.

Everyone except new forumers will know what the hidden post means - leaving those posts unhidden is of no benefit to anyone. The actions taken by the FMod will not be undone.

700 - Looks like that post has since been hidden :) Thanks

Jokku23 - the strike has been removed, the rest will remain on your account as it is recorded separately.

Thanks all,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

08-Jan-2016 11:35:53

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
700 - I've hidden post 5!

I suspect that post was hidden by a JMod - given that your post was the first response, leaving it there will have encouraged "silly" responses by other posters. As they were looking for actual feedback, your post was hidden.

Zoj - They can be the same thing.

Tclcis - Thanks, we'll keep an eye on things.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

12-Jan-2016 11:04:05

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
700 - Yes, I suspect that's it.

DoofMiester - As per the FMod's message, "creating a thread to discuss the behavior of other players and giving it a label is flamebaiting and attempting to stir things up. " The thread is not appropriate.

bluntmankj - please use the template given on the first post when posting on this thread.
Your threads have been locked correctly - I advise reading the Fmod posts when they lock, as they'll explain why. Listening to their advice will avoid future thread locks.

Avidsparkly - Agreed with the FMod action, your post was provocative and insulting the other user. We don't need it. Your ban was due to another post I believe.

Nexus0rigin - I've passed on your concerns to Mod Neena.

Thanks all,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

15-Jan-2016 12:09:10 - Last edited on 15-Jan-2016 12:09:19 by Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Avid Sparx - The FMod action was correct. The hidden posts were those that were personal attacks, and the note left was what was ther eto encourage everyone back on-topic.

High Warped - Due to very confusing posts and misleading over on that thread, I would ask that you comply with the FMod's advice. Keep it to price listings and keep the information factual.

Vivaire - It's similar enough that the earlier thread could have been copied to make the later thread. You can still use the earlier thread to post your ideas if you wish, I disagree that it can't be used that way.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

22-Jan-2016 11:18:12

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Sa1e - please use the format provided at the beginning of this thread to have the moderation reviewed - we need to look at the specific thread to make a call.

0z - Your post was off-topic and questioning FMod action, which is why it was hidden. Let the FMods do the moderation, please.

CSGB Matty - as you have been known to post flamebait on that thread before, your post was removed correctly. My best advice to you is to stop posting on that thread, your input is not needed there.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

25-Jan-2016 10:25:44

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Wilf - This wasn't really a discussion topic, it's better for the player to be moved as they can be helped. Looks like the owner was happy with the move so I'm not going to take action here.
The second thread has already been dealt with.

Vivaire - I've moved the thread to Existing game updates.

Ferenc2017 - The Fmod post was fair, it wasn't an attack but a piece of advice. The post is definitely not against the rules, nor unfair.

Thanks all,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

04-Feb-2016 16:53:11

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Hey guys.

FiFi La Frou - thanks for the feedback.

Big Storms - I understand your issue, unfortunately this situation is such that some users will see things different to others. I think the posts you mentioned are toeing the line, but not breaking any rules, so FMod action was correct.

Wilf - That stick is from 2012. I don't believe there's a need to unsticky it at this time.

Malpercio - FMod action is correct. The thread was degenerating and not achieving what it had set out to do.

Archaeox - I'll shoot you an inbox message.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

12-Feb-2016 16:44:30

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Conquerer - reviewing your posts, I believe you were only trying to stir up trouble in that situation, not something the forums need. Feedback like that should be given in-game.

Dumpster Cat - Thanks for the feedback, we have these rules to keep the forums positive and friendly. Although we could allow negative posting in a civil manner, we have not found that forumers are able to stay civil in most situations.

Whos-Dr - I've unhidden the post, not sure what that was about - apologies.

Matmano9 - Yes, it was due to quoting the original message, and the topic of discussion.

WBM - Your post is flamebait when you are not representing Jagex with your post. While small reminders are acceptable, acting as if you are a mod will not help the community.

KlNG OF FlRE - You were left a message explaining why the thread was locked. You don't need us to repeat the information.

Per Arne - Thread title change requests should go via Forum Help. I have changed it for you this time.

Iceberg - I've removed the sticky.

Vivy - the thread in question was naming and shaming, which is why the post was hidden. The player had also already received good advice for their issue.

WBM - I agree with the FMods comments on that thread, and my advice above still stands.

Avid Sparx - The message was hidden, but not all posts are worthy of further action. The FMods have guidelines set by Jagex which they follow for these situations.

Matmano9 - The thread you linked to does not have a post from your or the FMod you mentioned on it - think you might have the wrong QFC?

Silmarilli - I've unhidden one of the posts made, the other I agree was spam.

Silmarilli - Though the latest posts were not gravebumped, the thread has been gravebumped in the past. I agree with the decision to lock that thread.

Akos A - Unstuck the thread you mentioned, I will pass on a request to have the others reviewed.

MithrilShard - the posts were taking the thread off-topic, so the FMod was correct to remove them.

Big Slackend - your QFC led me to forum help. Can you show me the two clan threads and where messages were hidden/not hidden, and your posts reporting messages that should be hidden. I'll need this to be able to investigate the full situation.

ChaotiCake - please use the form at the beginning of this thread to report FMod behaviour.

Eva Element - Your posts were baiting and ultimately unnecessary

U are Death - I might consider allowing a thread discussing DarkScape to remain open in the PVP forum given it's also appropriate there, however, the thread in question is flaming and insulting and inapropriate. If you decide to recreate a thread that is constructive, feel free to include a link to this post in the thread so it can remain open.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

01-Mar-2016 14:09:51

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Vivy - Trust trading is when players must trade without receiving anything, on the understanding that they'll receive something else that is not possible to trade in the same trade window. This is not allowed on the forums because of the large amount of scamming that was ongoing when it was allowed. Fmod action was correct.

Vivy - It was locked due to gravebumping, as the latest post was made 2 months after the post before. Gravenumping is against the code of conduct, so the FMod action was correct.

LiberTPhoral - This will not be written down because it changes from forum to forum. Apologies, but that's the nature of this beast.

Kiara - I have reversed the decision as you've advised.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

04-Mar-2016 17:26:21

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Lady Deluxe - Thanks you for your feedback. I will investigate your claims and ensure everything is remaining fair. Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

11-Mar-2016 16:18:06

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Hey all,

Nexus0rigin - That kind of thread is not welcome on the forums - it's not entertaining, can mislead players, it was posted on the wrong sections which led the FMod to believe it was spam.

Lady Deluxe - we are done reviewing those actions. No further changes will be made. Move on.

TCLCIS - There's little more we can do in this situation. I see the post has now been locked and I apologise for the confusion in the multiple moves. Hopefully this can now be moved on from by the parties involved.

Thanks - wishing you all have a very happy Easter
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

24-Mar-2016 15:13:55

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Lady Deluxe - the template can be found at the beginning of this forum thread. You need to use it every time you post here. Doing so guarantees we can find what we need.

Legaia 2 Pla - Thank you for letting me know.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

29-Mar-2016 16:24:35

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Lady Deluxe - Thanks you for your feedback. I will investigate your claims going forward.

AmazonKaty - Dealt with now. Thanks!

Runite Mn - I agree with the FMod actions. You had been warned previously to bring it back on-topic and had previous posts on that thread hidden too, yet continued to argue with other forumers.

Blow Me Down - The thread was locked because there were many similar threads already up on the forums. Not personal against you, but threads in General that are on the same topic should be centralised to one place. Given the only advice anyone could give you at the time was "keep trying", yours was a thread that wasn't going to foster much more meaningful conversation.

On your second report, it will have been hidden due to your quoting a post that needed to be hidden.

Weaker Link - Thanks for the heads up, I'll monitor the situation.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

01-Apr-2016 14:38:04

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Chisp - The thread was closed correctly, and you know why.

Reactionary - I've locked the thread.

Low Warped - This report is better for Forum Help - the FMods are more likely to see your message before JMods are!

15 - the Fmod explained their action, I agree with their decision.

Weaker Link - thanks for your report, I'll pass this on for investigation.

Investor - Thanks for the report. Action is taken by FMods for the protection of the community - and we agree with the decisions they make there.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

07-Apr-2016 15:22:22

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Prison Nark - The behaviour of that player is in accordance with our rules - on some of the threads you mentioned I would consider your behaviour to be worse than theirs. No further action will be taken.

Alethros - Thanks for the heads up. After a lot of consideration, I've decided to stick with the moderator's decision. The rules of the forums can't really be skipped for one thread and I don't think it needs a sticky. Gravebumping is against the rules.

Chisp - The comment was off-topic and flammatory. The thread is under investigation - I would recommend keeping your posts polite and stick to the code of conduct to avoid further forum bans.

To your 2nd and 3rd posts, I'm not sure why this keeps coming up. You have been told plenty of times not to repost those threads. They will continue getting locked, and you know why.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

15-Apr-2016 12:27:14 - Last edited on 15-Apr-2016 15:22:20 by Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Lady Deluxe - the word is censored in-game, and I disagree that most people would be using that word appropriately ;) It will remain censored.

ff6 - Thanks, I will take your info into consideration.

MZ HellFire - Thanks for the heads up.

Chisp - We're getting tired of it too. You've been told not to post about items before.

Draco Burnz - Thanks, I'll investigate this.

Duq - If you've found other threads breaking the rules then the best thing to do is report it via forum help. Just because others are breaking the rules doesn't mean you can to - the FMods likely didn't noticed the other threads.

Ferenc2017 - Thanks, I'll investigate.

Thanks all,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

29-Apr-2016 13:52:25

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Amazonkaty - I just spent a while trawling through the posts on that thread but couldn't see anything supporting your claims. From what I can see the FMod action was correct.

Darkhawk288 - Whatever your intentions, the thread is seen differently by other people. As such, it needs to be remade as specified.

Wilf - The decision has been made now. Further questioning is a waste of your time and ours.

Long Hair 7 - The first post of the thread is quite clearly someone advertising their business. The tone of replies always follows the style of the forum, so I'm not surprised by the responses, however this does not justify the thread's existence in General. The opening post should be reworded if the creator wants to have a General-styled discussion.

FiFi La Frou - Noted

Draco Burnz - That post has since been hidden.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

11-May-2016 14:52:47

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
15 - Thanks for the report, no action will be taken from this thread and reporting in-game is the way to go.

Darkhawk288 - If you post on this thread again in regards to this report you will be banned. It has been reviewed.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

13-May-2016 11:31:51

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Avid Sparx - The FMod action was correct. We do not comment on bans to other players here.

That is the last we will here of this incident, thanks.

Grim Fortune - I have unlocked the thread in questions. Thanks

Jeffery - The thread was inappropriate. Fmod action is correct.

Ferenc2017 - GB'ing varies depending on the forum it's in. I agree with the FMod action in this case.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

20-May-2016 15:06:32

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Kiara - Thanks for the heads up.

Lnkmiegel - The CM team each takes a day on moderation in a given week to ensure the moderation of the forums remains unbiased.

In regards to your issue, you have been answered 3 JMod posts ago. If you post on this thread again in regards to the same issue we may be forced to take action against your account, as this is not an appropriate use of the thread anymore.

Chee - Thanks for the report, I agree with the FMod actions as that is the point of the whole forum. Although it's a nice sentiment it's also unnecessary, and where one forumer can do it, so can a lot more to the point it wouldn't make sense.

Vivy - Thanks for the reports, I'll investigate. I am however curious as to how you knew who had hidden threads when you are not able to see this information yourself.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

02-Jun-2016 14:20:27 - Last edited on 02-Jun-2016 14:21:23 by Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Hey,

Dj Klohver - Please use the format from the first post correctly to have something reviewed - filling in each section. IT is also helpful to complete your complaint within one post, and about the moderation you think was incorrect.

Lady Deluxe - You have also not used the format given on the first post.

FiFi La Frou - I don't find the post inappropriate, more just the FMod's personal opinion, which they are allowed to express.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

17-Jun-2016 16:42:03

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Nexus0rigin - I have unlocked the thread.

Lady Deluxe - The JMod explained his reasoning for locking the thread.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

24-Jun-2016 16:16:20

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
WAR_Jenny - Thanks for the report, I will discuss this with the FMod. However, please bear in mind how your posts can come across in the future. Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

01-Jul-2016 16:13:30 - Last edited on 01-Jul-2016 16:21:13 by Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Nexager - The forumers in question had warning and continued to post. The FMod action is correct.

Slackend - You were given HLF access. When you broke the rules and were removed from the forums temporarily since then, access was automatically removed by the system. Remember that HLF is a privelege, not a right.

The ali baba - It has been sorted now.

Blow Me Down - This a moderation review thread. I'm not sure what your posts are aimed at, but please use the format on the first post if you meant to post here.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

15-Jul-2016 14:30:35

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
FIaref0x - If the image has been removed by Imgur by the time the FMod comes to it, there is no need to remove the post. As I can't see the image, I'm not able to comment further on the decision.

D F Angel - The "story" that the player posted is not suitable to the forum roleplay and stories forum; I'll look into whether it's appropriate to create a forum for this.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

29-Jul-2016 15:14:28

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Weird Tomboy - Inaction isn't something we take action against the FMods on; they are volunteers. The user that you have reported isn't breaking rules of the forums; though I will keep an eye on what you've mentioned.

Long Hair 7 - I agree with the FMod decision to lock the thread.

Avid Sparx - Please use the format on the front page to report an FMod.

Deekthr - Thanks, I will feed back about this.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

03-Aug-2016 15:29:13

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Hey all, Happy Friday!

Lucine - It is not against the rules for an FMod to say that. I don't see any necessary action here.

Avid Sparx - The user was told to stop; action was taken by the FMod. It's not our aim to ban everyone on the forums, but encourage positive conversation. I agree with the action taken here.

Vivy - Fmod action was correct.

Amazonkaty - I've edited the title, but don't think the FMod did wrong - as it wasn't the PMod who made the statement but another user. Hope this makes sense :)

Lnkmiegel - 1. "to include a password reset link in the Account center, as well as a brief description of what it does."

2. I will look into this.

And to be clear, your questions are not an appropriate use of this thread. I have answered them anyway, but you need to stick to the format for the MRT in future.

Aurella - Thanks for the feedback, threads do not have to be moved by FMods however.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

05-Aug-2016 11:09:48

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Lnkmiegel - I don't understand the question you're asking here.

PeterBurke - All Fmods are monitored and given feedback. We are 100% confident and happy with the current team.

Vivy - I have edited the thread title.

Wilf - Thanks for the heads up.

Mean 2 U Man - I see the nicety of having the thread around, however bumps every 6 months are not what this forum is for. It would be better to leave an archive off the RuneScape website - hope this makes sense.

The TomBomb - The discussion is not based around a confirmed future update, therfore it is in the right section.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

09-Aug-2016 16:36:55

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Miu - The post contents have since been hidden.

Mean 2 U Man - Although I understand why you have appealed, my previous decision will not change, as it is per the forum rules.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

12-Aug-2016 11:23:14

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Low Warped - Your account being banned was explained. Fmod action was correct.

Guthixian - Swearing on the forums is not allowed.

Aorox - I get the sentiment, however the thread fits the guides forum better.

Thanks
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

19-Aug-2016 17:32:50

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
D4 BE45T - The situation has been dealt with and you were given a response. Arguing the point is only going to result in action being taken against your account. Thank you.

Mean 2 U Man - Gravebumping is not in the CoC or Specific rules as it is very different between the different forums. I will endeavour to change that; however, gravebumping is spam and is not allowed.

Deltaslug - Please use forum help for these issues.

cute girl420 - Please use the template from the first post on this thread, so I can understand what your issue is.

Torchic - I see your point, but the likelyhood of other players having the same issue is low. Having this thread stay near the top is not necessarily good for the forums either. I feel it's better for other players with the issue to create a new thread in however many months time, than keep that thread alive.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

26-Aug-2016 16:11:30

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
BARBlE GlRL - Thanks for the info. The matter has now been dealt with; but I will investigate and see if any further action is required.

TokHaar Gol - The images removed were inappropriate for the forums. FMod action is correct.

poorwasyday - this has already been dealt with.
Thanks for the heads up.

qyr - that is what the thread "Looking for Founders" is for. I don't recall allowing that thread I'm afraid?

Quivra - it looks like the text you are referring to is a secondary part to his post - the primary part being relevant to the discussion. I have no problem with this as he is doing it infrequently.

Thanks all,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

02-Sep-2016 15:10:34

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
QYR - I think the looking for founders thread is the best to use for that purpose - it's still ooking for leadership positions. There's no need for another thread.

Biscuits - I will investigate this, but there's no action needing to be taken.

Avid Sparx - I can't understand how that comment is on-topic. Correct action taken.

Mod Matthe to continue the catching up.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

12-Sep-2016 14:53:46 - Last edited on 12-Sep-2016 14:54:32 by Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Reactionary - I have taken action.

Kami Yuuki - There is more to this situation than meets the eye; no inappropriate action was taken.

High Warped - Dealt with. Please use forum help in future.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

21-Sep-2016 15:27:46

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Magpie - The decision stands; arguing this point isn't going to change anything.

TokHaar Gol - I locked the post and got distracted before posting; apologies. You'll note I did come back to it.

Eva Element - Your first line in that post is inappropriate; I don't even need to read further. Swearing on the forums is not allowed.

TokHaar Gol - I said to exclude the second picture, not censor it. FMod action correct.

5-x - Thanks

Strawberrys - I'd rather not take the risk I'm afraid. Linking to external websites doesn't work so I don't know what you've linked to; however it seems to me to be bending the rules and advising people to do that on these forums is dangerous activity, that is best to avoid.

Amy Bella - It was a bit flamey I'm afraid.

Cheers,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

30-Sep-2016 16:52:28

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Bernadette - Thanks - the post is hidden now but I thought I'd already done so :O Maybe someone else has hidden it since my post?

Dirty Notcha - You don't have a

TokHaar Gol - I'll pass this on to be reviewed by someone other than myself.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

07-Oct-2016 14:53:48

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Iceberg - Looks like that's already been sorted :)

Lego Miester - I have moved the thread; there's nowhere really good for it to go though :(

Avid Sparx - I will take action if appropriate.

Torchic - Dealt with

PvM Sasuke - It's a stretch to consider this advice. FMod action was correct
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

12-Oct-2016 16:36:23

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Le Pope Deux - Thanks for bringing this to my attention. Your thread was spam, I'm afraid to say, and 22 pages of "." is not a good use for the forum. You can use your bump button across the two threads.

I will look into solutions for other threads only filled with ".", because it's not what the forum is here for.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

19-Oct-2016 16:59:28

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Derek Booker - The rules are clear - gravebumping is not allowed and your threads have clearly been gravebumped. Whether ot not their initial discussion has been resolved.

Kentt - Thanks for highlighting, however no rules were broken in the post.

Nexus0rigin - Tuffty explained his reasoining and I agree - the thread didn't suit that forum.

DestinyNukem - it's been reviewed. Plagiarism is against the rules, I'm afraid.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

27-Oct-2016 16:23:07

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Nexus0rigin - it's been reviewed.

Kakamile - The issue with these threads is that they unerringly devolve into insults and flame aimed at Forum Moderators. JMods can't designate the time needed to effectively moderate such a thread, and if FMods did it they'd be called out for being unfair/biased.

The thread had run its course by then; nothing further could really be gained by it.

Malua - Ah-hah. Thanks, feedback will be provided.

Aurella - When the first post is hidden, that's the end of the thread. We'd prefer OP to create a new thread with the details after that, so if a different helper came along they'd know everything. Make sense?

Simply Peter - The rule in question states "You cannot show a specific player in a negative light, so no naming and shaming." The thread you've mentioned is not negative.

LtdruneLtd - No. Use the format given on the first post when you want moderation reviewed.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

01-Nov-2016 16:07:09

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
EMO Unicorns - though the second part of your post can stay on the forums, the first part is indeed an inappropriate use of that forum. The first part is clearly a rant, and so should be treated as such.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

18-Nov-2016 16:40:18

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Hey,

Mod Matthe is reviewing this overnight and will post a response in the morning - apologies for the missed day.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

05-Dec-2016 17:13:24

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Deltaslug - Looks like this has already been sorted :)

Bat Mask Man - There is no evidence to support your claim. Remember that you shouldn't trust what you see on the forums as it may not be 100% correct. Also, this is not an appropriate use of this thread - this is for a review of forum moderator action.

Canvas One - I'm not 100% clear on the rules around this but I shall forward it on to Mod Matthe.

Jamandy52 - that is not an appropriate use of this thread.

Cheers,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

05-Jan-2017 17:33:44

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Draco Burnz - Looks like it has since been dealt with

Iceberg - This has been dealt with by Mod Matthe

Bat Mask Man - Thanks for this information. As I have previously stated, this is not an appropriate use of this thread.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

06-Jan-2017 15:30:28

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Canvas One - Please use the format at the beginning of this thread. There's 115 pages on that thread.

Avid Sparx - The thread has been dealt with now.

Sicariu&KC - I have reversed the FMod action

Cheers,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

13-Jan-2017 15:58:40

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Bat Mask Man - best place to report this in the future is Forum Help, looks like it was just missed. Have sorted now.

Conqueress - Please use forum help for this in the future :) Looks like it's been sorted now.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

18-Jan-2017 15:40:34

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Aurella - Yep, I'm aware of it :) Not sure when I'll post.

Helicopter - Glad it's sorted

Bat Mask Man - FMods do not deal with price manipulation anymore to keep the forums calmer. We are indeed monitoring the thread.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

20-Jan-2017 14:20:52

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Hey guys, happy Friday!

Green Cafe & Werewolf - I have reviewed the thread and no rulebreaking action was taken. The previous thread was locked for rulebreaking, and all forumers can recreate a locked thread without the rulebreaking aspect.

I am Death - Your post is attacking the group on that fc, therefore was removed correctly.

Ta,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

03-Feb-2017 15:14:07

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Nexus0rigin - You'll notice Mod Matthe said it "may not be considered spam", not that it wasn't. The aim of the individual by their behaviour was clearly that of disruption and aggravation, therefore the thread was locked. Now, this discussion is finished and action may be taken against your account if you continue to waste our time on this subject.

sithspawn9 - Your issues are not appropriate to be dealt with on the forums, therefore the threads were removed.

Wilf - That didn't come across as humorous, but did as an attack on the mod.

Ta,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

21-Mar-2017 09:07:44

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
0815 - I have done as you requested and changed the post so the image was removed. Ultimately the episode you refer to is still about religion so isn't appropriate for the forums.

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

27-Apr-2017 15:51:40

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
0815 - Already hidden by the looks of it :)
Avid Sparx - FMod action was correct - you posts were uncivil.
Avid Sparx - Norne's comment was fair, the argument was becoming inappropriate and it needed to be stopped, I find the action taken appropriate.
Avid Sparx - I have taken appropriate action.
Nexus0rigin - Thanks, I have started investigating
0815 - I don't see any such thing here? How do you come to that conclusion?

Thanks,
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

28-Apr-2017 10:41:34

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Saddha - this thread is for Forum Moderator review. Your reports are not in reference to action forum moderators have taken, therefore they will not be responded to here.

You are better asking for help in forum help for these, as Mod Matthe has advised. We will no longer respond to your reports unless they are in relation to FMod actions.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

12-Jun-2017 14:05:42

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
In addition to Matt's response above;

#3 - not reported to forum help.
#4 - not reported to forum help.

Ensure your reports have gone through forum help before posting them here.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

12-Jun-2017 17:19:34

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Trips - As per our post in the Q&A on the new rules, we are still discussing what we can do to improve that forum. Therefore, no changes there yet. Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

16-Jun-2017 15:38:28

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Elf of Seren - thread has now been locked
Avid Sparx - Mod Matthe's and the FMod decision stands.
Dong U Dead - That thread has been locked
Jack Flac - No. That subject is massively innappropriate for the forums.
Konie Pan - Can confirm we understand the post properly - it's still about recruitment for a clan, even if more roundabout.
Dong U Dead - Has since been locked
Torte - Has been moved - I think you got the wrong thread by mistake, but if not please report to forum help :)
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

05-Jul-2017 10:50:23

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Shiavui - FMods do not have the ability to edit your posts for inappropriate content, so hiding them was the correct action. Reading the summary of the link you provided, there is inappropriate content there.

Raleirosen - I am questioning whether a thread like this has any place on the RuneScape forums. They come close to subjects which are banned here, and as you say are a very niche interest so there is little benefit in having it. The links being shared come close to breaking the off-topic specific rule of "I also play another game, can I tell everyone about it, because I think they might like it as well?". I'm keeping a close eye on it - but the FMod moderation is correct.

Jack Flac - similar answer to the above. Anime or Visual Novel, they still need to follow the rules - FMod action is correct.

Phree0 - The topic in question is not appropriate for where it was posted, FMod action is correct. Also in future, please follow the format given at the beginning of this thread.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

07-Jul-2017 11:02:07

Mod Kalaya

Mod Kalaya

Jagex Moderator Forum Profile Posts by user
Whatusaytome - if you don't want players to post, locking the thread is best. JMods can post despite thread locks.

Whatusaytome - If you are rule-breaking, action will be taken when it's reported. We adjusted the rules for greater freedom of forumers but the rules we have kept are for the safety of everyone and must be adherred to.

Whatusaytome - Your reply was not a report it was arguing with another player - which is a mis-use of the thread.

SonOfWar - Can you indicate where the moderation has taken place for us to look into this please.
Mod Kalaya |
Zarosian
Product Manager | @JagexKalaya

18-Aug-2017 14:16:26

Quick find code: 254-255-527-65726664Back to Top