Mayudzukisaid: I've used dozens of keys over the past few days, and I've gotten nothing but bonus experience and free experience, which I don't want and have never wanted.
I have skills at 40+ that I've never even TOUCHED because of the free experience treasure hunter gives. (Seriously, 60 smithing from protean bars? This is out of hand.)
It's gotten to a point where I'm literally converting most if not all of my rewards into Oddments just so I can get something I feel like I've been rewarded for something.
I'm not even saying you need to take bonus experience out completely, but it would be nice to see anything from treasure hunter other than a new type of bonus experience. jagex would make less money with your idea here, hence it's unlikely they will do sobring back the lumbridge pig pit