Nijisaid: please email me they owe me keys, they have my personal information, this is a scam as far as i'm concerned.
SuperRewards and Peanut Labs are typically very prompt in responding to any reward disputes.
I had problems with resolving an issue with Peanut Labs and Jagex Payment Support Team was extremely accommodating. Of course, you're going to need to provide sufficient evidence to show you completed the offer but as long as you did complete the offer, you're pretty much guaranteed your reward, whether it comes from the third party or Jagex.
Be sure to follow Tren's advice.
You know that feeling you get when you try to wear goblin mail but realize you can't?