That's a lot of work and I honestly don't think we will gain much from it. Probably could have made a D&D to give the gameplay people wanted. I think this is a case where the players are pushing something that has little value, just so they can pat themselves on the back for making you go through with it.
I will just let you do what you will, cause in the end it makes little difference. I like to choose my battles and this certainly ain't one of them.